Investing is a probabilistic enterprise. Since certainty is even rarer than high risk-free returns, we’re left trying to make the best decisions we can based upon the knowledge we have. If we do that extremely well, we might be right *most* of the time, but still a long ways away from *all* of the time. The improbable — the highly unlikely even — happens and happens surprisingly often.

Take yesterday’s NFL action, for example. More specifically, consider the astonishing Vikings v. Ravens game in snowy Baltimore.

The Ravens and Vikings set several records yesterday, but perhaps the best of them was that the lead changed hands *six* times in the 4th quarter, That had never happened before. There were six touchdowns in the fourth quarter alone, with five of them — and four of them on plays exceeding 40 yards — coming during the final 2:05 of the game. The teams combined to score 36 points over that final 2:05, by far the most combined points late in any game over the last 50 seasons, per Elias Sports. In fact, before yesterday’s madness, the fastest five touchdowns (*anytime*) in one game over the past 50 years required more than 5:30. It’s almost incidental to note that Baltimore won the contest, 29-26.

The good folks at Advanced NFL Stats run a win probability metric throughout games to show the likelihood of each team’s winning after each play based upon score, down, distance, and time using an enormous data-set of NFL history. This analysis provides a good way to examine, monitor and evaluate the decision-making of NFL teams and coaches.

Take note of the win probability chart for Vikings v. Ravens yesterday. It’s wild.

Source: Advanced NFL Stats

With 1:05 left and the Ravens ahead, 22-19 (following a Jacoby Jones 77-yard kick-off return), the Vikings had only a 6 percent chance of winning. After a 79-yard touchdown pass by the Vikes, the extra point, and a touchback on the kick-off, the odds had completely reversed. But after the Ravens scored again and the replay official upheld the score, the Ravens won despite the odds. In fact, over the final three minutes, the Vikings’ win probability flip-flopped from 87 percent to 20 percent to 76 percent to 6 percent to 93 percent before they lost. We should call it the “fat tail” game. Minnesota had a 93 percent chance of winning and travelled home disappointed nonetheless ( as a point of comparison, the 49ers had a lower win probability after going ahead of Seattle, 19-17, with 31 seconds remaining yesterday).

As Joe Flacco understated it, “It was unlikely that we win this game today, but we did.”

So the next time you run your various investment models and Monte Carlo simulations to conclude that you have — say — a 93 percent chance of success, remember the Vikings yesterday. Things can go south in a real hurry. The unlikely happens with surprising frequency. A 93 percent chance is not a sure thing, not by a long-shot.

Pingback: Stock Selection Part III | Prudent Trader

Pingback: Worth Reading | Above the Market