There is a famous story, almost surely apocryphal, that makes the rounds with some regularity in our industry. As the story goes, a new, struggling advisor buys a mailing list of 10,000 potential prospects. He then writes two separate newsletters about the same, high beta stock. One newsletter advises a leveraged short of the stock and is sent to half of the list. The other newsletter suggests a leveraged buy of the same stock, and is sent to the other 5,000 prospects.
A month later, the prospects that got the newsletter touting the wrong side of the trade are discarded. The 5,000 that were on the right side are split into two groups and the same process is repeated with a different stock. He does the same thing again two more times. At the end of four months, the advisor has a list of 625 prospects who can’t believe their luck in finding the next Michael Burry (or Seth Klarman or Warren Buffett). Of course, they will also spend the next ten years wondering why, after they transferred their life savings, the magic disappeared.
Remember this story every time you consider a money manager or fund’s performance history or think about another “hot” pundit’s recommendations in print or on business television. The markets are binary. They can only go up or down and are in this way similar to a coin toss, at least in the sense of probability. The odds of getting four calls in a row right are actually fairly low: 0.5*0.5*0.5*0.5 = 6.25% probability. Similarly, if we started with a group of 1,024 people and had them pair off and compete in coin tosses with the winners advancing, by the time we reached the ultimate winner, she would have won 10 contests in a row. That’s a result that is nearly as unlikely in the particular as it is inevitable in the aggregate. Good performance alone – even over significant time periods – is not enough to recommend a money manager or fund.
None of this is to suggest that every manager with good performance is just lucky. It is merely representative of the hurdles in the way of advisors searching for managers that are actually good at their jobs and not just rolling the dice. Past performance, as we are taught, is no indicator of future results. Investing skill is – at a minimum – very hard to find.
This multiple-part project is designed to try to ascertain where and how value in the markets may be found. I hope you enjoy it.
The Value Project (2): Commit to Diversification
The Value Project (3): The Value Proposition
The Value Project (4): Emphasize Process
Pingback: The Value Project (2): Commit to Diversification | Above the Market
Pingback: The Value Project (3): The Value Proposition | Above the Market
Pingback: The Value Project (4): Emphasize Process | Above the Market
Pingback: The Value Project (5): Other Stuff | Above the Market
Pingback: The Active Mangement Challenge | Above the Market
Pingback: Value is Elusive | Above the Market
Pingback: Outstandingly Mediocre | Above the Market
Pingback: Demand for Hitmen and Yield | Above the Market
Pingback: Voting with their Feet and their Dollars | Above the Market
Pingback: Happy Blogiversary to Me | Above the Market
Pingback: 7 Super Bowl Investing Lessons | Above the Market
Pingback: Establishing Your Top 10 Investment Default Settings | Above the Market
Pingback: The Tuned Market | Above the Market
Pingback: Financial Advice: A Top Ten List | Above the Market
Pingback: AAII Citations | Above the Market
Pingback: Finance blogger wisdom: a post-Bogle world | Abnormal Returns
Pingback: Something Wicked This Way Comes | Above the Market
Pingback: 2013′s Best (#9): Something Wicked This Way Comes | Above the Market
Pingback: 2013′s Best (#3): Financial Advice: A Top Ten List | Above the Market
Pingback: 2013′s Best (#1): Establishing Your Top 10 Investment Default Settings | Above the Market
Pingback: Kobayashi Maru and the Forecasting Follies | Above the Market
Pingback: Underestimating the Density of the Fog | Above the Market
Pingback: Diruangan classrom | aperiusndruru
Pingback: A Call for Kintsugi Portfolios | Above the Market
Pingback: A Call for Kintsugi Portfolios – extremeconsultingincblog
First of all I would like to say superb blog!
I had a quick question which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
I was interested to know how you center yourself and
clear your mind before writing. I’ve had trouble clearing my thoughts in getting
my ideas out there. I truly do take pleasure in writing however
it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes
are lost just trying to figure out how to begin. Any suggestions or hints?
Many thanks!
My best advice: just write. Your first drafts will always be lousy. Get something on the page and work from there.
Thanks for reading.